Based in the outskirts of Chicago, Sweet Mischief® LLC, specializes in custom sugar cookie favors for events, gatherings or your personal indulgence. All cookies are made from a scrumptious, buttery sugar cookie base (choose from basic or chocolate) and decorated with royal icing. They are freshly baked with no preservatives; contain eggs and milk*.


Our Story

It all started with a chocolate chip cookie. Yes! A chocolate chip cookie recipe that people were craving on a consistent basis. From there evolved other cookie flavors and baked goods before deciding to focus our niche on the cut-out, decorated sugar cookie (shout out to our cookie God-mother, Anne who inspired this craft) . Most cookies are decorated with royal icing – a perfect and sweet combination to indulge.

With hundreds of cookie cutters to choose from, we can create a favor for almost any occasion. All cookies are hand cut and intricately decorated.

  • Baby

  • Birthday

  • Bridal

  • Cause/Awareness Ribbons

  • Fraternity/Sorority

  • Graduation

  • Holidays including Easter, Christmas, Kwanzaa and Hanukkah

  • Wedding

Interested in something not listed? Just ask using the contact form below.

Our Mantra

Sweet indulgence is permissible and special occasions should be celebrated without compromise.



*Cookies contain the following allergens: eggs, milk and wheat and are produced in a home kitchen not subject to public health inspection that may also process common food allergens.

About image